“Fence-mania” – a problem of Polish cities
2026-10-06
When international visitors come to Poland’s major cities, one of the things that catches their attention, alongside the architectural diversity, is the sheer number of fences. Fences made of steel, wire mesh, concrete or wood surround not only private detached houses, but also modern multi-family housing developments. Polish cities have been fragmented into thousands of enclosed enclaves; fences sometimes appear even when it is difficult to identify any specific threat they are intended to protect against.
The phenomenon has acquired its own name: the Polish term “płotoza”, or “fence-mania”. It refers to the urge to fence off residential and public spaces. Although residents may intend a fence to guarantee security, privacy and prestige, in practice it has become an urban blight. It damages the urban and social fabric, obstructs pedestrian movement and makes it more difficult to move between housing developments.
Why have Poles embraced fences?
Fencing is not an exclusively Polish invention. Gated developments exist in many countries and are studied by urban planners and sociologists. In Poland, however, the phenomenon has its own distinctive characteristics.
To understand why fencing became so deeply rooted in Poland, it is necessary to look back to the 1990s. Following the political and economic transition, after many years of the socialist Polish People’s Republic, private property became increasingly important. With it came a desire to separate private space clearly from shared space. In this sense, a fence was more than an ordinary security measure. It became a symbol of private ownership, independence and control over one’s immediate surroundings. After a period, when residential space had largely been organised by the state and housing cooperatives, having a place of one’s own that was private and clearly separated, took on additional significance. The plot boundary ceased to be merely a line on a cadastral map; it had to become a solid physical barrier separating “our clean and safe space” from “the foreign and unpredictable”.
Several key psychological and market factors have reinforced this trend:
- the security myth: crime rates in Poland were higher in the 1990s than they are today, so many people were more concerned about burglary and theft. Developers began to use these fears to market homes. Fences, entrance barriers and security personnel were intended to give residents a sense of safety and protect them against burglary, car theft and vandalism.
- Exclusivity and social status: during the first two decades of the 21st century, a gated development was associated with luxury, financial success and higher material status. The fence separated a “better world” from the rest of the city.
- The desire for control and exclusion: a wish to remain separate from people, who do not live in the development, such as noisy young people, neighbours from nearby blocks walking their dogs or homeless people.
Over time, fences came to be erected not only by homeowners’ associations in upmarket developments, but also by housing cooperatives managing prefabricated apartment blocks and even by developers building the least expensive estates on distant urban outskirts. Fence-mania became a widespread standard.
Urban paralysis
From an urban-planning perspective, excessive fencing can have long-term adverse effects on urban space. A city is a living organism that requires unobstructed “blood vessels” – pedestrian routes, cycle paths and streets – in order to function properly. When space is divided by fences, these routes are abruptly severed.
Pedestrians feel the effects most acutely. Fences often force them to take longer routes and walk around entire developments, even when their destination is just beyond the fence. They prevent natural movement through the city. A parent with a pushchair, an older person or a child must make detours along narrow, shaded corridors beside fences, often without a pavement. Space that could serve as a welcoming square or green public area loses some of its functionality and accessibility.
Fence-mania ceases to be merely a matter of convenience when lives are at risk. For years, the fire and rescue service, ambulance service and police have warned that gated developments and closed entrance barriers can drastically increase response times. Ambulance crews and firefighters may encounter difficulties when trying to access gated developments, including locked gates, faulty or unavailable access systems and obstructed fire routes. In an emergency, every obstacle can further delay their arrival at the scene.
The security myth and the social consequences of ghettoisation
Does a fence really protect against crime? Numerous studies in criminology and urban sociology, including the SafeGrowth approach to designing safer places, show that in most cases fencing provides only an illusory sense of security.
Paradoxically, a high fence and an enclosed site may actually make matters easier for criminals:
- Lack of natural social surveillance: the best protection against crime is the presence of people on the streets, often described as “eyes on the street”. A fence enclosing a development creates dead, empty zones along its perimeter. Once a burglar has crossed the fence, they may feel safer behind it because it shields them from the view of passers-by outside.
- Weaker ties between neighbours: residents of gated developments often know their neighbours less well. Greater anonymity makes it more difficult to notice unfamiliar or suspicious individuals.
- Stigmatisation and hostility: a fence creates a division between “us” on the inside and “them” beyond it, generating tensions between neighbours. Fences can also reinforce social divisions. Access to better designed and maintained spaces is restricted to residents of particular developments, contributing to pronounced disparities between different parts of the city.
A market trap: when a fence reduces property values
For years, developers argued that fencing increased the market value of a home. The market is now beginning to challenge this view.
While buying a home in a gated development was a source of pride in the early 21st century, it is now increasingly seen, particularly by younger buyers from Generation Z and the Millennial generation, as a legacy of a previous era that does not necessarily meet residents’ current expectations.
Moreover, fences undermine the commercial potential of housing developments. Cafes, bakeries and small service businesses do not open on ground floors cut off by fences because they lack access to customers from outside. The development becomes a dormitory devoid of urban life. In the long term, homes in such gated developments may be less attractive than those in open, well-connected parts of the city.
Tackling fence-mania: can fencing be brought to an end?
Awareness of the harmful effects of the fencing culture is growing among both urban planners and local government officials. Poland is gradually beginning to move away from this approach to spatial design.
Efforts to tackle fence-mania draw on several complementary legal, planning and social tools. The first are municipal landscape resolutions, which introduce binding local rules prohibiting new fences in designated zones and thereby effectively prevent further fragmentation along major streets or across entire districts. The second are precise provisions in Local Spatial Development Plans (MPZP), requiring pedestrian routes to remain open and unobstructed and prohibiting fencing, which compels developers to design an open urban fabric. These top-down mechanisms are complemented by urban activism and growing interest in the YIMBY (Yes, In My Back Yard) movement, which promotes the development of more open, accessible and well-connected neighbourhoods. Local residents’ initiatives may also drive bottom-up changes, such as reducing existing fencing or restoring publicly accessible routes.
Examples of this shift can be found in cities such as Krakow and Gdansk, where local regulations restrict the fencing of multi-family residential areas. Similar measures are currently being prepared in Warsaw as part of work on the city’s landscape resolution.
Summary
The fence-mania is more than a characteristic feature of the Polish landscape. It is the consequence of a particular way of thinking about ownership, security and space. For years, a fence represented protection from the outside world. Today, however, it is becoming increasingly clear that a city is not composed solely of private properties. It is a system of interconnected spaces, and every additional barrier changes the way it functions. The problem, therefore, is not the mere existence of fences. It arises when every property begins to function as a separate island.
A fence can protect a home. It can provide privacy. It can give residents a sense of security. However, when successive fences begin to divide an entire city into separate enclaves, their cumulative effect may be the opposite of what was intended: instead of a safer, more convenient city, they create a space that is less accessible, less coherent and more difficult to use collectively.
When international visitors come to Poland’s major cities, one of the things that catches their attention, alongside the architectural diversity, is the sheer number of fences. Fences made of steel, wire mesh, concrete or wood surround not only private detached houses, but also modern multi-family housing developments. Polish cities have been fragmented into thousands of enclosed enclaves; fences sometimes appear even when it is difficult to identify any specific threat they are intended to protect against.
The phenomenon has acquired its own name: the Polish term “płotoza”, or “fence-mania”. It refers to the urge to fence off residential and public spaces. Although residents may intend a fence to guarantee security, privacy and prestige, in practice it has become an urban blight. It damages the urban and social fabric, obstructs pedestrian movement and makes it more difficult to move between housing developments.
Download report