A house on a neighbour’s plot – does it have to be demolished?
2026-11-02
You have owned your house for years. You have a notarial deed and a land and mortgage register confirming your title to the property. You decide to sell the house, and everything appears to be progressing smoothly. Then a problem suddenly emerges: the building turns out to stand partly or entirely on your neighbour’s plot.
For the owner, this often comes as a considerable shock. An even greater problem may arise, when a bank refuses to accept the property as security for a loan. The transaction is put on hold, the buyer begins to withdraw and the seller must find a solution they had never previously considered.
What options are available in this situation? Can the property’s legal status be regularised without demolishing the building?
Why does a boundary problem emerge only when the property is sold?
Many problems relating to property boundaries remain unnoticed for years. The owner lives in the house, tends the garden and carries out renovations, with no reason to suspect that the building extends beyond the boundaries of their plot.
The situation most commonly changes when the property is sold, the plot is subdivided, an extension is planned or a mortgage is sought.
A bank considering the provision of finance must assess the property offered as security for repayment of the loan. The property’s technical condition and location matter, but so does its legal status. If there are doubts about the plot boundaries or the building’s location on land belonging to another person, the bank may regard the security as carrying excessive risk.
How can a house come to stand on someone else’s plot?
There may be several reasons for such a situation. One is an error or inaccuracy in the surveying records. Property boundaries may have been established many years ago, and the available materials do not always make it possible to reconstruct their course conclusively without further work.
Another reason may be that the building was erected too close to the boundary or crossed it during construction. Sometimes the problem concerns only part of a structure, such as a corner of the house, a garage or another outbuilding. In other cases, an entire building extends onto the neighbouring land.
Nor can it be ruled out that the current owner purchased the property without being aware of the discrepancy. Documents concerning title to the land and records showing the building’s actual position are not always sufficient to identify every problem without a more detailed analysis.
What should be checked when a building is found to cross a plot boundary?
The first step is to determine whether the problem arises from incorrectly marked boundaries, inconsistencies in the records or the building’s actual placement on land belonging to another person.
It is advisable to begin by reviewing the documents relating to the property, in particular:
- the land and mortgage register and documents confirming title;
- an independent as-built survey of the building;
- historical maps and surveying records;
- data held in the land and buildings register;
- the available construction documentation.
The assistance of a licensed surveyor will be required to assess the materials and determine whether additional measurements or formal boundary procedures are necessary.
This is a crucial stage. Moving a fence, indicating a boundary on a map or relying solely on the owner’s belief as to where the boundary lies cannot be assumed to resolve the legal problem.
Only after the facts have been established and the documents analysed is it possible to assess which solutions may be available in the particular case.
How can the situation be regularised?
There is no single solution suitable for every case. The appropriate course of action depends, among other things, on the area of land occupied, the circumstances in which the building was erected, the neighbour’s position and the documents relating to both properties.
If the statutory conditions are met, the transfer of ownership of the developed land may be sought, while the property owner may require the other party to purchase the relevant part of the plot.
Under Article 231 § 1 of the Polish Civil Code, this is possible where the neighbour possesses the property as if they were its owner, acted in good faith when erecting the building or other structure, and the value of that building or structure substantially exceeds the value of the occupied part of the land. The claim may concern, among other things, a garage, fence or road, but not plantings alone. As a rule, the purchase covers only the necessary part of the plot and takes place in return for payment corresponding to its market value. If the statutory conditions are not met, the owner may demand the return of the land, while the possessor may seek reimbursement for expenditure incurred in accordance with the applicable provisions.
Acquisitive prescription as a means of resolving the dispute
If a building has stood for many years on land formally belonging to a neighbour, one possible solution is acquisition by prescription. Under Article 172 of the Polish Civil Code, ownership of real property may be acquired by prescription after:
- 20 years, in the case of possession as owner in good faith;
- 30 years, in the case of possession as owner in bad faith.
To seek a declaration of acquisition by prescription from a court, it is first necessary to:
- gather evidence confirming possession of the land as owner, such as witness statements, photographs, invoices or documents concerning the use of the property;
- obtain a survey map precisely marking the area covered by the application for acquisition by prescription;
- submit an application to the district court with jurisdiction over the location of the property.
Acquisition by prescription may regularise the legal position without requiring the building to be demolished, but the statutory conditions must be met. It should also be remembered that the mere fact that a building has stood on another person’s land for many years does not automatically mean that ownership has been acquired by prescription.
Pursuing claims through the courts
If an agreement with the neighbour cannot be reached, court proceedings may need to be considered.
Polish law contains provisions governing, among other things, situations in which a building or other structure crosses the boundary of neighbouring land. Article 151 of the Polish Civil Code, which concerns crossing a boundary when erecting a building or other structure, may be relevant, as may other provisions depending on the circumstances of the case.
This does not mean, however, that every homeowner is automatically entitled to demand the transfer of ownership of the occupied land or that the neighbour must always agree to a particular solution. The application of specific provisions depends on the statutory conditions and the facts established.
In such a situation, a legal review of the documentation and the history of the building’s construction is particularly important. It makes it possible to assess which claims may be available to the respective parties and whether court proceedings are genuinely necessary.
Summary
A house may stand on a neighbour’s plot for years without the situation being noticed. The problem often emerges only when the owner wishes to sell the property or the buyer applies for a mortgage. At that point, a discrepancy concerning the land boundaries may make it difficult to establish security and cause the transaction to be put on hold.
This does not mean that every such case is hopeless. The key steps are to establish the true course of the boundaries, analyse the documentation and select a solution suited to the particular circumstances. In some cases, correcting the records will be sufficient; in others, an agreement with the neighbour, the acquisition of part of the land or the pursuit of appropriate claims will be required.
Most importantly, the problem should not be left until the bank refuses finance and the buyer begins to consider withdrawing from the transaction. An earlier legal and surveying review may help reduce costs, save time and improve the prospects of successfully regularising the property’s legal status.
Download report